Skip to content

Unit 93 — Relative clauses 2: clauses with and without who / that / which ​

核心主题 ​

这一单元继续学习:

Relative clauses(关系从句 / 定语从句)

重点解决一个非常重要的问题:

什么时候 who / that / which 不能省略?

什么时候 who / that / which 可以省略?

核心判断方法:

看 who / that / which 在关系从句中是主语(subject),还是宾语(object)。


A. who / that / which 作主语时:不能省略 ​

先看 Unit 92 的例子:

The woman who lives next door to me is a doctor.

住在我隔壁的那个女人是一名医生。

也可以说:

The woman that lives next door to me is a doctor.


1. 分析句子结构 ​

关系从句是:

who lives next door to me

把 who 换回它代表的人:

The woman lives next door to me.

这里:

who = the woman

而 the woman 是动作:

lives

的主语。

所以:

who 是关系从句的 subject(主语)


因此:

✅ The woman who lives next door to me is a doctor.

✅ The woman that lives next door to me is a doctor.

不能省略:

❌ The woman lives next door to me is a doctor.


2. that / which 作主语 ​

再看:

Where are the keys that were on the table?

之前放在桌子上的钥匙在哪里?

也可以:

Where are the keys which were on the table?


把关系词换回原来的名词:

The keys were on the table.

这里:

that = the keys

而:

the keys

是:

were

的主语。

所以:

that 是关系从句的 subject

因此不能省略。


核心规则 1 ​

当:

who / that / which = 关系从句的主语

必须保留:

不能省略。

结构:

名词 + who / that / which + 动词

例如:

the man who works here

the car that broke down

the book which is on the table


B. who / that / which 作宾语时:可以省略 ​

有时候:

who / that / which

不是从句的主语,而是:

object(宾语)

这时候就可以省略。


3. who 作宾语 ​

例如:

The woman who I wanted to see was away on holiday.

我想见的那个女人去度假了。

关系从句:

who I wanted to see

原来的结构是:

I wanted to see the woman.

分析:

I = subject wanted to see = verb the woman = object

所以:

who = the woman = object


因此 who 可以省略:

The woman I wanted to see was away on holiday.

这完全正确。

也可以保留:

The woman who I wanted to see was away on holiday.

两种都可以。


4. that 作宾语 ​

例如:

Did you find the keys that you lost?

你找到你丢失的钥匙了吗?

关系从句:

that you lost

原来的句子:

You lost the keys.

分析:

you = subject

the keys = object

所以:

that = the keys = object

因此 that 可以省略:

Did you find the keys you lost?


核心规则 2 ​

当:

who / that / which = object

可以:

省略关系词

所以:

the woman who I wanted to see

可以变成:

the woman I wanted to see


the keys that you lost

可以变成:

the keys you lost


5. 更多例子 ​

保留关系词 ​

The dress that Lisa bought doesn’t fit her very well.

Lisa 买的那件连衣裙不太合身。

省略关系词 ​

The dress Lisa bought doesn’t fit her very well.

两种都正确。

因为原始结构:

Lisa bought the dress.

the dress 是宾语。


再例如:

Is there anything that I can do?

有什么我能做的吗?

可以省略:

Is there anything I can do?

因为:

I can do something.

这里 something / anything 是 do 的宾语。


6. 如何快速判断能不能省略? ​

这是这一单元最重要的技巧。

观察关系词后面是什么。


情况 ①:关系词后面直接是动词 ​

例如:

the man who works here

结构:

who + works

who 自己就是主语。

所以:

❌ 不能省略


the car that broke down

结构:

that + broke

that 是主语。

所以:

❌ 不能省略


情况 ②:关系词后面已经有另一个主语 ​

例如:

the man who I met

关系词后面:

I

已经是主语。

说明:

who = object

所以可以省略:

the man I met


再例如:

the book that I bought

that 后面已经有:

I

所以:

that = object

可以省略:

the book I bought


最实用的判断口诀 ​

看到:

who / that / which + 动词

通常:

不能省略

例如:

the man who works here


看到:

who / that / which + 主语 + 动词

通常:

可以省略

例如:

the man who I met

↓

the man I met


7. 省略后不要再加代词 ​

例如:

the keys you lost

正确。

因为:

the keys

已经是 lost 的宾语。

不能说:

❌ the keys you lost them


同样:

the dress Lisa bought

正确。

不能说:

❌ the dress Lisa bought it


为什么?

原始句:

Lisa bought the dress.

合并以后:

the dress Lisa bought

the dress 已经承担了 bought 的宾语作用。

所以不能再加:

it


C. 关系从句中的介词位置 ​

这一部分非常实用。

重点是:

to / in / for / with / on 等介词

在日常英语的关系从句中,通常可以留在:

从句末尾


8. talk to ​

原本两个句子:

Tom is talking to a woman.

Tom 正在和一个女人说话。

Do you know her?

你认识她吗?

合并:

Do you know the woman Tom is talking to?

你认识 Tom 正在和她说话的那个女人吗?


也可以保留关系词:

Do you know the woman who Tom is talking to?

或者:

Do you know the woman that Tom is talking to?

这里:

to

仍然放在最后。


结构:

the woman + Tom + is talking to

这在日常英语中非常自然。


9. sleep in ​

原来的句子:

I slept in a bed.

我睡在一张床上。

It wasn’t comfortable.

它不舒服。

合并:

The bed I slept in wasn’t comfortable.

我睡的那张床不舒服。

也可以:

The bed that I slept in wasn’t comfortable.

The bed which I slept in wasn’t comfortable.


10. look for ​

例如:

Are these the books you were looking for?

这些就是你一直在找的书吗?

也可以:

Are these the books that you were looking for?

Are these the books which you were looking for?

注意:

look for

是一个整体:

寻找

所以:

for

留在句尾。


11. sit next to ​

例如:

The man I was sitting next to on the plane talked all the time.

我在飞机上坐在他旁边的那个男人一直说个不停。

也可以:

The man who I was sitting next to ...

或者:

The man that I was sitting next to ...


12. 不要重复宾语 ​

正确:

the books you were looking for

错误:

❌ the books you were looking for them

因为:

the books

已经是 for 的宾语。


正确:

the man I was sitting next to

错误:

❌ the man I was sitting next to him

因为:

the man

已经是 to 的宾语。


常见结构 ​

日常英语里经常出现:

the person I talked to

我与之交谈的那个人

the company I work for

我工作的公司

the house I live in

我住的房子

the chair I sat on

我坐的椅子

the problem we talked about

我们讨论的问题

the person I went with

和我一起去的那个人


这些句子虽然最后有介词:

to / for / in / on / about / with

但完全自然。


D. Everything that ... / What ... ​

继续比较:

that

和:

what


13. Everything + that ​

我们说:

Everything that they said was true.

他们说的一切都是真的。

也可以省略 that:

Everything they said was true.

因为:

they said everything

这里:

everything = object

所以 that 可以省略。


不能说:

❌ Everything what they said was true.

因为:

everything

已经是先行词。

后面应该使用:

that

或者省略。


14. all the money + that ​

例如:

I gave her all the money that I had.

我把我所有的钱都给了她。

可以省略:

I gave her all the money I had.

不能说:

❌ all the money what I had


15. What = the thing(s) that ​

what 本身的意思是:

the thing(s) that

所以:

What they said was true.

他们说的话是真的。

等于:

The things that they said were true.


这里没有:

everything

the things

something

等先行词。

因为:

what

本身已经包含:

the thing(s) that


that 和 what 的核心区别 ​

前面已经有名词 / 代词 ​

使用:

that

例如:

Everything that I know

我知道的一切

The things that I bought

我买的东西

All the money that I have

我所有的钱


前面没有先行词 ​

使用:

what

例如:

What I know

我知道的事情

What I bought

我买的东西

What I need

我需要的东西


Unit 93 最重要的核心:主语 vs 宾语 ​

这是整个 Unit 93 最值得掌握的内容。

① 关系词是主语 → 不能省略 ​

例如:

The man who called me is Tom.

给我打电话的男人是 Tom。

关系从句:

who called me

原始结构:

The man called me.

所以:

who = subject

因此:

❌ 不能省略


② 关系词是宾语 → 可以省略 ​

例如:

The man who I called is Tom.

我打电话给的那个男人是 Tom。

原始结构:

I called the man.

所以:

who = object

可以说:

The man I called is Tom.


一组非常重要的对比 ​

The man who called me ​

给我打电话的男人

原始句:

The man called me.

所以:

who = subject

不能省略。


The man I called ​

我打电话给的男人

原始句:

I called the man.

所以:

the man = object

关系词可以省略。


再对比一组 ​

The car that hit me ​

撞我的那辆车。

原始句:

The car hit me.

that 是主语。

所以:

❌ 不能省略


The car I bought ​

我买的那辆车。

原始句:

I bought the car.

that 是宾语。

所以可以:

The car that I bought

或者:

The car I bought


快速判断表 ​

结构关系词作用能否省略
the man who called mesubject❌ 不能
the man who I calledobject✅ 可以
the car that broke downsubject❌ 不能
the car that I boughtobject✅ 可以
the book which is expensivesubject❌ 不能
the book which I boughtobject✅ 可以

最快判断方法 ​

不要一开始分析复杂语法。

直接观察:

关系词后面有没有主语?

没有其他主语 ​

the man who works here

who 就是主语:

❌ 不能省略


已经有主语 ​

the man who I work with

I 已经是主语:

who = object

所以:

✅ the man I work with


Unit 93 最终思维模型 ​

text
名词
 │
 ├── who / that / which 是从句主语
 │
 │      ↓
 │   不能省略
 │
 │   the man WHO works here
 │   the car THAT broke down
 │
 └── who / that / which 是从句宾语
        ↓
     可以省略

     the man (WHO) I met
     the car (THAT) I bought
     the book (WHICH) I read

一句话记忆 ​

关系词自己“做动作” → 不能省。

例如:

the man who works here

是 who 在 work。


关系词是“动作的对象” → 可以省。

例如:

the man (who) I met

是 I 做 meet 这个动作,而 the man 是被我见到的人。

所以:

主语不能省,宾语可以省。

这就是 Unit 93 最核心的规则。